During public comments at the Jan. 12 city council meeting, local physician Dr. Tonda Bradshaw read a statement written by a nurse at home in quarantine. The statement expressed the opinion that the city should not join the county’s lawsuit to end COVID-19 lockdowns.

Impassioned and long, two individuals ceded their time to ensure the full statement could be read. At three minutes per person for public comment, Dr. Bradshaw was due nine minutes of time. Mayor Bogh cut her off at six.

The city attorney explained in a letter regarding the incident that Mayor Bogh decided ceding of time was not allowed during public comments. However, this was not announced to the two individuals who stood up to cede their time to Dr. Bradshaw. In fact, the minutes from the meeting reflect that they indeed ceded their time. Ceding of time has always been allowed at previous city council meetings.

The city attorney’s explanation also does not match the audio recording of events. When Dr. Bradshaw objected to being cut off early, she was told that she “only had two (people’s time).” Mayor Bogh then stated that the third slip indicated time was ceded to “Dr. Bradshaw.” She responded that “Dr. Bradshaw” was standing right there. The mayor replied that this was not what was on the speaker slip, implying that the woman who stood before him could not be Dr. Bradshaw.

Whether a genuine mix-up or a sexist gaffe, the city had the opportunity to apologize and correct their error at the next meeting but failed to do so, neglecting to acknowledge their mistake or amend the minutes to reflect what happened. Meanwhile, the city attorney drafted spurious defenses. Extending former Mayor Avila’s metaphor from his outgoing speech in December, Yucaipa City Council continues to drive recklessly in its own version of “Mr. Toad’s Wild Ride.”

Arianna Huhn



(1) comment


The city council is populated by incompetents whose sole duty in life is rubber stamping the horrible decisions of the city staff. Meanwhile the condition of the streets is deplorable, the traffic lights are all screwed up, the budget squanders money on the performing arts center causing Avila and the past council to invent a scam tax increase, the public safety budget is out of control because the vaunted city staff doesn’t negotiate effectively. The city salaries, benefits and pensions are obscenely high for a city of our size.

The new members of the council need to correct course. Get a city engineer that knows how to resurface the streets other than slurry coating. Get a city manager who has some vision instead of tax increases. You were elected to run the city not turn it over to unelected city bureaucrats.

Get with the program Council or we will replace the rest of you!

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.